Kevin S.
12/14/2023
I'm a 67 year old white male with an affinity for good home cooking. I started going to the whistle stop after my mom told me I ate way too many pancakes. I ate 67 in one sitting at the whistle...
Whistle Stop Tavern
$$
Closed
(6)
Photos
# 3
Carthage, NY 13619
Whistle Stop Tavern is a cozy establishment nestled in the heart of Carthage, NY, offering a welcoming atmosphere for locals and visitors alike.
With a focus on providing a comfortable space to enjoy good company and drinks, Whistle Stop Tavern is a popular spot for those seeking a relaxed and friendly environment.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
4.06 reviews
Caroline J.
9/18/2020
Kind of a hole-in-the wall place with decent food and good service. Not much to look at from the outside and the inside isn't that spectacular either, but it is clean. Tried their burnt ends...
Robin A.
9/4/2019
Best chicken wings anywhere!!! Love this place, history, bartenders, clean, variety of things to do, pool, darts, shuffle board...atmosphere and cold beer! Menu looks fabulous, think I will bring...
Alicia O.
2/11/2020
We went to the whistle stop for their ribs night. Whole lot of good food at an amazing price. The ribs were nice and tender. The bbq sauce was alright not great but not bad. The pickles and...
Lucas C.
4/30/2022
So it burned down... no room or walls, kitchen collapsed, uninhabitable. Condemned by fire department, currently being Bull dozed.
See a problem?
