John S.
8/24/2025
Was hesitant to try this place after reading the reviews. Glad we ended up here. Had the ribs and brisket. Both were very good. Nice smoke ring in both, along with being tender. The ribs came...
When Pigs Fly BBQ Pit
$$
Closed
(154)
Photos
8254 1st St
Westfield, NY 14787
When Pigs Fly BBQ Pit is a family-owned restaurant in Westfield, NY, specializing in West Texas-style BBQ. With a menu crafted by renowned Chef Robert Hesse, they offer smoked meats prepared with a secret red rub and a blend of Hickory, Cherry, and Applewood for a unique flavor experience.
Located on the picturesque shores of Lake Erie, the restaurant features beach access, volleyball courts, and a tiki bar, creating an inviting atmosphere for summer fun. Additionally, their cozy winter setup includes a fireplace and stunning views of the frozen lake, making it a year-round destination for BBQ lovers.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0154 reviews
Ivy Y.
7/25/2024
Loved it. Came with friends on our motorcycles and the food was very good. Service was quick and the vibe was very casual. We sat outside at a table with an umbrella for shade. It was nice. I...
Erin H.
8/15/2025
Don't usually write reviews but When Pigs Fly was very Disappointing - Ribs were very dry jerky like- BBQ salad was just microwaved chicken on a salad with cold fires. Service was slow but...
Kathy S.
6/29/2025
We've been here a few times over the years. Atmosphere is good, nice spot on the beach. Servers are always friendly. However, went here today (Sunday afternoon) with our 4 kids, it wasn't busy. We...
Brianna L.
8/3/2025
I have been here many times before and it only got worse. We already know that the wait is long so when we came here we expected it. We like to come because the views and direct access to the lake...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.