Varney's Restaurant

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(194)

Photos

2109 Montauk Hwy
Brookhaven, NY 11719
Family owned and operated seafood restaurant. Serving the best lobster roll, baked clams, and mussels no-frills eatery with American classics plus fresh mussels & clams. We've been a staple roadhouse nestled in the scenic town of Brookhaven. Serving the community with excellence for over 40 years.https://www.facebook.com/varneysrestaurant

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0194 reviews
Photo of Manuel C.
Manuel C.
9/26/2025

Small hidden gem on maintain highway. I always have passed and wanted to stop and finally one day was today. I was cruising in my classic car just having me time and I stopped and had the cod fish...

Photo of Chuck G.
Chuck G.
8/17/2025

Cute local joint on the South Shore. Food was delicious. From the appetizer to dessert everything was great. The waitress was wonderful too. Everyone talks about the main course, but the lowly...

Photo of James R.
James R.
9/14/2025

Was down here for work... naturally I wanted some New England soul food... lobster rolls I do myself but I did want some fried cod and some scallops. Farney's is a nice little shackish joint.. and...

Photo of Anthony M.
Anthony M.
7/28/2025

This lobster was slammin! Filled with good pieces of lobster loaded with flavor and butter! No fancy work here just simple and delicious. The clams were also flavorful and full of bits of clam in...

Photo of Jacqueline H.
Jacqueline H.
7/8/2025

Great server and attentive runner! My mom has been on a lobster roll mission. She has had 3 in one week! This was the third and she said it was by far the best. I had fried shrimp which had a...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkBrookhavenVarney's Restaurant

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.