Jon C.
8/3/2025
Closed for building renovations until mid August. Check on website for updates. Love their food. Waiting for reopening.
Utica Pie Co.
Closed
(59)
Photos
594 Mamaroneck Ave
White Plains, NY 10605
Utica Pie Co. is a renowned pizzeria that originated in Upstate New York in 1910, known for its iconic Tomato Pie that has been satisfying the cravings of Central New Yorkers for over a century. With a rich history deeply rooted in the region's Italian traditions, this family-owned establishment brings the famous pies of Upstate New York to the heart of Westchester, offering a delectable selection of well-done, Italian-style pizzas, pasta, and other specialties.
Utica Pie Co. takes pride in its authentic Italian-made dishes, crafted with a special dough, delicious sauce, mozzarella, and a variety of toppings, all baked to perfection. From the pioneers of the famous Utica Pies to the great-great-grandparents who laid the foundation, this pizzeria brings a taste of tradition and heritage to the lower Hudson Valley, inviting visitors to experience the best of Utica-style Italian cuisine.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.559 reviews
Renée C.
2/9/2024
Update: I like the Plain pie with pepperoni better than the special/Utica pies. Took over an hour to be ready on a Friday so put your order in early. My ambiance was waiting in the parking lot...
Leoncio T.
2/5/2025
Absolutely amazing pizza! It's Utica style. Which is different than NY style. The crust is a bit thicker and it's a bit saucier. But, it's pure delicious. The ingredients are top quality and...
Babak H.
12/21/2024
Unique Pizza, great service, always great taste . You won't be disappointed, probably the best non-NYer pizza around.
Carmen P.
6/12/2024
I'm in White Plains for work and just DoorDash pizza, wow amazing I got cheese and spinach and the bread is amazing. If you like bread with your pizza, you will not regret this. I would definitely...
See a problem?
