Nikkeya N.
9/22/2025
I am so madly and deeply in love with the food here! OMG!!! It's crazy just how good it is. I stopped in one day after googling what food was near me. I forgot that they moved to Kenmore and the...
Tortuga Sandwich Shop - Kenmore
Closed
(16)
Photos
3189 Delaware Ave
Buffalo, NY 14217
Tortuga Sandwich Shop in Kenmore, Buffalo, is celebrated for its unique and flavorful sandwiches that have garnered rave reviews from customers. The shop prides itself on using quality ingredients and meticulous presentation, making each sandwich a delightful experience.
Patrons have praised standout menu items such as the Gustavo and Salmita, with many expressing eagerness to return and explore the full range of offerings. Additionally, the shop's churros have also received commendations, further enhancing its reputation as a local gem.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.516 reviews
Elizabeth Betsy B.
10/3/2025
The only things I had here-- first time, last Tuesday-- were the Agave Lime Slaw, Mac 'n Cheese, and the 420 Style Fries. Will try a sandwich next time. The other reviews here pretty much say it...
gary s.
9/24/2025
Tried to get in here last week and got here at 6:20 and they were already closed. We weren't too happy but decided to give them another shot. We had been to their location in Sanborn years ago and...
Kate B.
8/30/2025
Oh my gosh this was so good!! I read a step out buffalo article about this place, and in the same week got two more recommendations so we had to try it! We got takeout last night for dinner and...
Alexander E.
9/20/2025
This unassuming, no frills restaurant is a hidden gem. When we visited, it was completely empty. But the food was outstanding. I ordered the Choripan, and it was both filling and flavorful. I'd...
See a problem?
