Colleen G.
9/23/2025
Excellent and so many choices! I wanted to order a sub, but couldn't resist getting a couple of pizzas slices too
Tony's Pizzeria
$
Open
(33)
Photos
435 Mohawk St
Herkimer, NY 13350
Tony's Pizzeria is a classic Upstate NY eatery known for its thick crust pizza. The restaurant offers a variety of tasty treats, including pizza topped with mushrooms, peppers, and buffalo chicken, catering to different flavor preferences. Customers appreciate the generous portions and find satisfaction in the quality and value of their meals.
Alongside their signature pizzas, Tony's also serves fries, making it a great spot for a hearty meal. The quick service ensures that diners can enjoy their meals without long waits. With a focus on comfort food, Tony's Pizzeria is a favored choice for pizza lovers in the area.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
4.033 reviewsSusan Z.
7/6/2025
Great spot! The pizza was delicious and the customer service was A++. The restaurant was clean and quiet. This was super easy to get to off the freeway and a great spot on our long drive from Lake...
Veronica W.
4/7/2024
Yummy and filling pizza extremely reasonably priced served with a smile! As a person from New Jersey, I'm always curious about styles of pizza other places. I was pleasantly surprised; this pizza...
Liv K.
9/2/2024
Cute place, easy access off the thruway, but...the pizza, are we in Chicago? How can you not offer thin crust slices? All bread, burnt cheese, and a minimal amount of mediocre sauce up by the...
thaddeus j.
2/7/2022
The pizza is always extremely greasy and it had overall a decent taste nothing to bad to say. Very good Crisp. The ranch is decent. 6.8 / 10
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.