Raj S.
6/19/2025
Conveniently located within Woodbury common outlet mall.. right inside the food court . So many other shops and restaurants around .. kids decided to eat pizza and garlic bread and we bought it...
Tony + Benny's
$
Closed
(26)
Photos
498 Red Apple Ct Ste FC10
Central Valley, NY 10917
This new restaurant concept is based on our very own owners: Anthony & Biagio Scotto, who came over from Italy with family to Brooklyn to start a business. This upscale Brooklyn themed pizzeria features quality ingredients like 100% whole milk mozzarella, fresh sauce and homemade dough that we use to prepare out pizzas, Stromboli, specialty pies, pizza fritta, and everyone's favorite…zeppoles!
Also at this address
Reviews
2.026 reviews
Dan S.
11/16/2024
I know I ordered a pie but felt like I waited a very long time (more than usual). When I asked to change to go,I was told that would be fine but when my order was ready it was for here. Seems like...
Debbie D.
2/21/2025
Holy Price Gauging. $6.50 for a slice & $14 for a combo. So $7.50 for a fountain drink + side.. my check came out to $22 I said WTF. He said oh because you chose wings as a side.. so 3 mini wings...
jon l.
11/27/2023
The pizza here was just ok, and could likely have been better, because it was cold. They had recently opened and there was no line, so there are no excuses. The staff were friendly but unhelpful....
Marina K.
6/18/2024
The pizza is served hot and delicious we ordered 4 slices and a Caesar salad which was very fresh. Service was fast and friendly.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.