Lou B.
3/25/2017
Great little place on Montauk Highway in Sayville just west of the village. A lively atmosphere with an old time feel. The sandwiches are out of this world. There's thirty (yes thirty!)...
The Portly Villager
$
Closed
(52)
Photos
261 Main St
Sayville, NY 11782
The Portly Villager, located in Sayville, NY, is a beloved local pub known for its casual atmosphere and warm hospitality. Patrons appreciate the festive decorations that change with the seasons and the inviting ambiance created by a cozy fireplace during winter months.
This eatery offers a delightful selection of sandwiches and an impressive beer menu, making it a popular spot for both groups and families. Visitors often commend the generous portion sizes and the exceptional service provided by the friendly bartenders, creating a memorable dining experience.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.552 reviews
Will H.
4/23/2022
Had time to kill before our 2 pm appointment at the shabby tabby cat cafe that's just down the street, so we came in and checked out the portly villager. It's definitely a "locals bar." That...
Joelc73 ..
5/1/2025
Small, local place. A good selection of beers and some really cool sandwich options. Worth a stop if you're in the area.
Paul A.
8/2/2024
So this place is a great dive bar and apparently they are know for their sandwiches. I had the signature Portly sandwich and it was ONE OF THE BEST SANDWICHES I HAVE EVER EATEN!!!!! It was really...
Alicia B.
5/29/2024
This was a pleasant surprise. We decided to try it and have dinner the other night . The bartender was wonderful.( he should get a raise for sure) he was tending bar and serving patrons who sat...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.