Kerri B.
8/31/2025
The pizza here is always SPOT ON! We tried hot honey pepperoni, another similar with sausage (OMG yum!), and a Caesar salad wrap with cheese baked on the outside(I'm hooked). Staff is wonderful,...
The Pizzeria of Islip
$
Closed
(50)
Photos
591 Main St
Islip, NY 11751
The Pizzeria provides online ordering and delivery, catering, pizzeria to Islip, NY area.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.050 reviews
Chip P.
7/5/2025
The pizzeria in Islip has a great location on Main Street, the inside is open and airy with an extra room, and the service is friendly and quick. They have a great lineup of slices, some specials...
Lori S.
6/9/2025
I had an event catered on Sunday, May 25th at my home. One of our trays, Endless Summer Shrimp Pasta, was way too salty. Everyone took one bite and put it down. I called the restaurant on...
Emily B.
6/15/2023
Honestly super surprised by this local spot! It used to be Pizza Parm which I was not a fan of at all. The pizzeria has exceptional speciality iced and a solid plain as well. I tried the hot...
Tafseer U.
3/15/2025
Best Taste of Pizza, we enjoyed and staff was so good polite and hotel interior design was owsm
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.