Jessica C.
5/24/2025
The pizza here is very good, we did the large pizza and 20 wing special. Pizza was delicious, wings were crispy. What more could you want in a buffalo pizzeria ? Food was out fast, and service was...
The Pizza Heist
$
Closed
(71)
Photos
231 Aurora St
Lancaster, NY 14086
The Pizza Heist in Lancaster, NY is a renowned restaurant that has been serving up gourmet pizzas since 2012, offering a unique selection of toppings like onion rings on their popular Rodeo Pizza.
With a commitment to using fresh ingredients, their skilled cooks deliver high-quality food and exceptional service, making it a go-to spot for families looking for a delicious meal. The Pizza Heist also actively engages with the local community, participating in events such as the annual Taste of Lancaster, where they have proudly won first place two years in a row.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.571 reviews
H L.
3/22/2025
First time trying the Heist. Excellent in and out service, Pizza flavor was an "A", the price was right, and they did not disappoint! Highly recommend.
Phil W.
5/13/2024
Super clean interior, friendly cashier at the register. Perfect presentation on the pizza, sauce is on the sweet side and it had the perfect amount of cheese. Pizza logs, well they're pizza logs....
Sandy A.
4/27/2025
I had a coupon for a cheese and one-topping pizza at a reduced price, so I figured "why not use it". When I called to order, I told them that I had the coupon. The pizza was ready on time, and...
Katie G.
12/26/2023
Their chicken finger pizza is absolutely the best in town. Lots of chicken, perfect amount of cheese and blue cheese as the base! Delicious.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.