Winnie M.
5/30/2025
I love the pizza here. My favorite pies are the supreme and the garlic and shrimp. Great place for take out or dine in. You can combine two pie flavors except you can't do a salad with a hot...
The Pie at Salvatore's
$$
Closed
(177)
Photos
120 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
The Pie at Salvatore's is a renowned establishment in Bay Shore, NY, known for its uniquely delicious coal-fired pizzas. With a rich history dating back to 1933, when Great Uncle Patsy and Aunt Carmella opened Patsy's in Harlem, the restaurant has upheld the family's traditions and recipes, ensuring a truly authentic dining experience.
Continuing the legacy of hard work and dedication, The Pie at Salvatore's offers a mouthwatering selection of pizzas cooked in a coal-fired brick oven, guaranteeing a distinct and flavorful taste that has captivated patrons for generations.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0177 reviews
Steve P.
4/17/2025
My wife and I walked in not knowing they didn't serve pizza but the slice. I convinced her to stay and order and see how it was. Thankfully we did, because the food was incredible and we were...
Christina H.
3/17/2025
Homey pizzeria, small menu but really good pizza, can bring the entire family. Good wine super affordable. Service is excellent. I was craving a salad, the Caesar salad hit the spot. Opted for a...
Katie C.
4/12/2025
Great experience! Group of seven for dinner 7pm on a Friday. Place was packed but we were able to be seated right away. Waitress was very nice, very attentive. We got garlic bread and two pies and...
Lenny F.
3/9/2025
Place sucks after new management took over. Not the same from 4-5 years ago. The staff is ignorant and nasty and just could not be bothered even for a catering party in house. Go to "The Pizzeria...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.