Sandy N.
9/29/2025
What can I say, delicious pizza! We order for team lunch all the time. It's always crowded so that's the testament how popular this place is.
The Original Little Italy
$
Closed
(14)
Photos
2 E 39th St
New York, NY 10016
The Original Little Italy isn’t just a name -- in fact, we’ve been serving fresh pizzas, subs, and other Italian favorites in our neighborhood since 1969. A lot has changed since those early days, including our location a few times, but our dedication to preparing top-quality meals hasn’t changed a bit. From slow-fermented, hand-stretched dough and pizza sauce made in-house to homemade pasta dishes and filling subs on hot-out-the-oven bread, everything on our menu is made the right way, and you’re sure to taste the difference. Whether it’s your favorite pie, a refreshing salad, or cheesy lasagna you’re craving, we’ll always have your fix, and we’ll serve it up fresh and fast for a price you’ll love.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.514 reviews
Jonathan C.
6/8/2025
Pretty solid NY slice here. Garlic knots are also a steal. No complaints on the pizza or the garlic knots, they were fairly priced and tasted great. The very first pizza place I went to after...
Hector S.
7/25/2025
This pizzeria has phenomenal wings and some of their pizzas look delicious. The size and amount of toppings on some of the slices make the pizza look extra appetizing. I tried their plain pie and...
Sharyn L.
9/25/2024
I had a perfectly decent slice of veggie pizza for lunch. The crust was delightfully crisp, and the ratio of cheese to sauce was good. It wasn't quite warm enough or fresh enough to warrant 5...
Dan W.
8/26/2025
Outstanding slice- great texture, perfect thickness, not greasy. Great people- very nice.
See a problem?
