The Islander

Food and service excellent!! Best salads and fried fish sandwich!!! Crispy fabulous chicken tenders!

Was on shelter island for the day and stopped by for an early dinner at the diner. It was pretty empty and took about 40 minutes to get our food, but no complaints as we were on island time. I...

It's like you've just stepped onto a movie set. The room is a no-fuss, cafeteria meets diner space. Minimal and clean. And it's obviously the favorite restaurant on the island for the locals....

I decided to stop at the Islander last Friday for a burger. The restaurant was empty and smelled of paint. Apparently that was due to new ownership and some redecorating. I ordered a cheeseburger...

"Maybe" because there are not too many options on the island. I've been going to this same space from its earliest days as Pat & Steve's. The food was never fabulous but you could have a group eat...