Cassidy N.
11/19/2025
Today was my first experience at The Mustang Deli (The Ice Cream Sandwhich)...amazing. The sandwiches are made to order with fresh ingredients. I ordered a hot chicken with pepper relish, onion,...
The Ice Cream Sandwich
Closed
(9)
Photos
1 E Main St
Marcellus, NY 13108
The Ice Cream Sandwich is a quaint and charming establishment nestled in the heart of Marcellus, NY. Specializing in handcrafted ice cream sandwiches, this shop offers a unique and delightful treat for locals and visitors alike.
With a focus on quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations, The Ice Cream Sandwich provides a refreshing and indulgent experience for customers looking to satisfy their sweet tooth. Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or adventurous creations, this shop has something to offer for everyone.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.09 reviews
Wesley M.
12/29/2024
It's no longer Soft Served IceCream season any more, but that's okay. The service and staff are friendly, polite and make sure you are taken care of. The breakfast sandwich's are good to go and...
Haley T.
7/8/2025
Since renamed the Mustang Deli but we were saddened to see that the ice cream sandwiches are premade :( we received large portion sizes of the hard ice cream and the service was very friendly...
James A.
8/27/2025
Nothing stood out or overwhelming exciting on the menu. Sandwich I got was eatable but that's all. Prices a bit high for the lack of quality. I miss nojams and there deli !
Tim S.
7/28/2025
Fantastic deli- under the radar! Very fresh bread and outstanding meats and sandwich options. Get the Mustang and do yourself a favor! We will definitely be back.
See a problem?
