Phyllis Rosello M.
8/25/2025
We had a really fabulous experience this weekend at The Homestead! We were seated on the outdoor patio, and the view was just lovely. The grounds really are beautiful! Our meal was excellent,...
The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge
$$$
Closed
(48)
Photos
1040 State Route 55
Eldred, NY 12732
The Homestead, a Sullivan Catskills classic, has been reborn at The Eldred Preserve as The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge, a modern steakhouse offering a true farm-to-table experience. Enjoy classic fare from the original Homestead, along with contemporary farm-to-table comforts courtesy of Chef John Botti, a graduate of the renowned Culinary Institute of America and chef-owner of John's Harvest Inn in Middletown, N.Y. for 30 years.
Several unique experiential spaces have been incorporated, including a wine-tasting room, a private dining room, sunroom dining, and large outdoor terraces. Floor-to-ceiling windows offer restaurant and lounge patrons unobstructed views of the picturesque ponds, a stream, and the tree-covered hillside beyond.
Reviews
4.048 reviews
Theresa S.
9/29/2025
The atmosphere wonderful, server great, food was over priced for what it was. We ordered med rare filet came well done. Loaded potatoe extremely dry. Calamari was actually very good. Would never...
Joan F.
6/14/2025
Server was good. Place was very pretty but meal was very sub-par. Overpriced overcooked lobster. Overdone chicken. Paid bill, left tip, notified hostess of disappointment and left. Contacted...
Izzy N.
6/1/2024
I always like starting on a positive note. My server Samantha was great! I've always loved this place going back 20 years when it was a fishing pond to go fishing. The location is beautiful,...
Donna F.
9/17/2024
I gave it 4 stars because I ordered the duck, and unfortunately, it was dry. The waitress brought me more sauce and that seemed to help. The salad was very good and so was the dessert. Overall...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.