Gina S.
8/26/2025
The cookies were delicious!! The staff is knowledge and super helpful. Ordering a special birthday cake for this weekend.
The Cookie Shop
Closed
(24)
Photos
115 Mark Tree Rd Unit 6
Centereach, NY 11720
The Cookie Shop in Centereach, NY offers a delectable selection of macarons, cookies, and tart cakes. The bakery is a delightful destination for those with a sweet tooth, providing a range of freshly baked treats to indulge in.
With a charming storefront on Mark Tree Road, The Cookie Shop invites visitors to explore their menu filled with a variety of sweet delights. From classic cookies to unique tart cakes, there is something for every dessert enthusiast to enjoy.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
4.524 reviews
Sandy T.
9/3/2024
Came here to grab some cookies for the family. I got 3 large stuff cookies for $11. All of them tasted good but our favorite was the lemon with berry jam. None of the cookies were overly sweet and...
Angela J.
7/14/2025
I ordered my daughter's "18" on their website which makes the process so much easier than calling or stopping by. The even better part was that the cake was to die for!!! 10/10 on appearance AND...
Andrea F.
2/23/2024
Who knew?! As an avid follower of their Instagram account @thecookieshopli, I stumbled upon the fact that they actually have a storefront tucked away in a strip mall not too far from me. It was...
Lauren G.
8/15/2024
I wanted to say a big, 'Thank you' as the cake was amazing! Enjoyed by everybody. Absolutely fabulous - we can't thank you enough - the everything was amazing and tasted absolutely delicious!...
See a problem?
