The Cookie Odyssey

yelp logo

(12)

Photos

1414 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10021

Reviews

yelp logo
4.512 reviews
Anthi A.
9/19/2025

Amazing quality ! So gooey ! They have really good coffee as well by Devocion :)) I would definitely go back !

Photo of Melissa G.
Melissa G.
8/15/2025

I was in the mood for sweets when I walked past The Cookie Odyssey. Everything looked good, I decided on a pecan pie cookie and a chocolate chip muffin top, both were really fresh and delicious....

Photo of Whitney D.
Whitney D.
8/5/2025

This cookie store just opened in the area. There is no seating really to enjoy your cookies or coffee. There is a small bench by the window. It is super cute and very clean. The person working...

Photo of Hannah H.
Hannah H.
7/22/2025

The Cookie Odyssey has been around since the 'late 70s, and they are now in UES! Try their 'cookie and milk' combo, which includes a bottle of Battenkill Valley Creamery's milk - super cold,...

Photo of Nicole N.
Nicole N.
7/26/2025

Checked out The Cookie Odyssey at their new UES location! The Odyssey was probably my favorite out of the three and the Chocolate Coconut my second. I appreciated how their cookies were crunchy on...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkNew YorkThe Cookie Odyssey

Partial Data by Foursquare.