Joe H.
6/21/2025
Awesome local candy shop in the heart of town. Tons of verity, and charm! They even had the old school dot candy on paper that brought me back 30 years to my childhood!
The Candied Anchor
$$
Open
(31)
Photos
721 Montauk Hwy
Montauk, NY 11954
Montauk's newest self serve candy bar! Something for everyone, from nostalgic candies, to new favorites.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.531 reviews
Vanessa W.
10/26/2023
Always a friendly face when visiting! Our family always makes a quick visit to the Candied anchor with each visit to MTK. Unique selection, great beverage selection including specialty ice coffees...
Kathy X.
10/9/2018
This is a super sweet & adorable shop with all kinds of yummy, unique, specialty and retro candies from all over the world. The place is small and can get crowded quickly but boy, is it chock full...
Nicholas G.
10/11/2020
Candy shops seem to be the go-to place in Montauk. Unfortunately, you cant go in the store but you can order some stuff at the door. Damn Covid... They have every candy you could possibly think...
Joan L.
7/17/2018
Take a step back in time for n this retro themed sliver of a candy shop. For a tiny place, the Candied Anchor is jam packed with tons of candy and chocolate. You can find the retro treats of your...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.