Shira F.
6/1/2025
This is our favorite bagel shop in the neighborhood. Their egg sandwiches can't be beat. We usually split a sausage egg and cheese but we do pepperjack cheese and add avocado and a hashbrown...
The Better Bagel
$
Closed
(93)
Photos
45 Merrick Rd
Amityville, NY 11701
The Better Bagel in Amityville, NY offers a diverse menu of delicious bagels, sandwiches, and soups for customers to enjoy. With the convenience of online ordering and catering services available, customers can easily satisfy their bagel cravings.
Located on Merrick Road, The Better Bagel prides itself on providing high-quality food and exceptional customer service. Whether stopping by for a quick bite or planning a catering event, customers can expect a satisfying experience at this local bagel shop.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.093 reviews
Aikeem V.
6/9/2024
Stopped in to get a breakfast sandwich and iced coffee. I ordered a BEC on a bagel. Everything I ordered came out correct and fast, even though the line was literally out the door. After...
Andrea R.
8/5/2025
I usually go here for the bagels. Their Asiago bacon egg flagel is so good. But today I tried their Italiana Uno sandwich. I'm not a mortadella fan so I subbed it out for turkey. I'm also not a...
Judith L J.
9/2/2023
This was my first time visiting this shop. I love bagels. If I can get cheddar cheese, chicken and bacon on one, I'm in heaven. That's exactly where I went when I bit into this sandwich. We went...
Erik G.
10/27/2024
Great staff and even better bagels! Every bagel we ate was delicious!! Only problem is I don't live close enough to visit daily
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.