Wayne Y.
1/4/2016
It's a little drab in here. The lighting is old and the clientele is as well. It's one where people mosey in and out slowly. This is perfectly fine! But don't expect a bustling energetic place for...
Sutton Cafe
$$
Open
(34)
Photos
1026 1st Ave
New York, NY 10022
Sutton Cafe is a cherished diner nestled in the heart of New York City, offering a delightful taste of home-style cooking. Customers can relish in a variety of over 60 dishes, each crafted with care and passion. The ambiance is further enhanced by the friendly and attentive elderly staff, creating a truly inviting and warm atmosphere.
With a prime location at 1026 1st Ave., Sutton Cafe provides the convenience of both delivery and pickup options for orders. Emphasizing the importance of supporting local businesses, the cafe encourages patrons to order directly through their website rather than third-party platforms. Whether you're a local or a curious tourist, Sutton Cafe promises a culinary experience that will leave you wanting to come back for more.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
2.534 reviewsJohn P.
7/19/2025
Food is gross for starters. The atmosphere resembles a retirement home. The owner is obnoxious and gives orders to staff that are clueless.
Zack G.
6/30/2020
Small little diner has a decent amount of basic American entrees, but is really nothing special. I would say that the average age of the regulars ranges somewhere between 70-90 y/o I came for...
Sarah G.
1/23/2023
Sutton Cafe is a no frills small diner which seems to host an older crowd of regulars. On a Sunday during brunch time we saw mostly tables of 1 to 2 but there were a couple tables of 4 too. It's a...
Andre C.
12/7/2019
Personally, I am a huge fan of underrated-looking diners like Sutton Cafe. Though not very warm, restaurants like Sutton have a local feel to it that I appreciate. Nevertheless, my experience at...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.