Jeffrey H.
8/10/2025
This is definitely a try once out of curiosity place, but the value is in the experience rather than the ice cream! First, there is minimal signage out front, you walk in and it's an empty room...
Surprise Scoop
Closed
(21)
Photos
139 1st Ave
New York, NY 10003
Surprise Scoop is a delightful eatery located in the heart of New York NY known for its unique and creative ice cream flavors. With a vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff it offers a fun experience for ice cream lovers of all ages. Guests can enjoy a variety of toppings and mix-ins making each scoop a personalized treat. Whether you're looking for a sweet dessert or a refreshing snack Surprise Scoop is the perfect stop to satisfy your cravings.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.021 reviews
Amanda Z.
3/25/2025
This place gets five stars because it is exactly what it says it is. You walk in the place is painted with question marks (very on the nose very much everything is a surprise) you order on an...
LaToya E.
3/31/2025
Surprise scoop was such a random side quest! but it is exactly what it says it is. You walk in order a scoop and get whatever they give you and you need to be happy with it. I went with friends...
Melissa M.
2/16/2025
What a ride! 10/10 for experience and thrill. We passed by this shop unexpectedly and saw the sandwich board advertising. Ice cream roulette. Immediately intrigued. And the experience did not...
Jia-Lian L.
3/26/2025
This is a fun little idea. A bit dystopian. I dont know if its nice or depressing? Maybe both? I certainly wouldnt like every shop to be like this. Anyway, the ice cream I got was decent but...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.