Linda D.
8/19/2025
Went with a reservation. Service was excellent! Drinks were good. The toasted marshmallow martini was really good. The watermelon one was ok. Bread was good! Baked clams were good. Nice and...
Surfside Inn
$$$
Open
(51)
Photos
685 Old Montauk Hwy
Montauk, NY 11954
Surfside Inn in Montauk, NY, is a family-owned establishment that has been serving the community and visitors for over thirty-four years. Originally operating as a Hotel Restaurant under different names, the Inn retains a rich history, including its use as Coast Guard billets during World War II, and embraces the motto "Montauk The Way It Used To Be."
The restaurant is renowned for its freshly prepared local seafood and prime steaks, complemented by the exquisite views of the Atlantic Ocean. The Inn offers beautifully decorated rooms with ocean views and is conveniently located near a path leading to a serene beach and the Montauk Village.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.051 reviews
Ken S.
9/2/2025
Waiter was great his name is Rodger. The tuna special was terrible. It was dry with no taste. My wife said I should return it but did not want to get Rodger in trouble. The sweet potato fries...
Christina S.
7/16/2025
Beautiful location with stunning views, be sure to call and reserve a table for two on the front deck. Lovely menu with a variety of choices. The drinks were great and not watered down and were...
Linda K.
7/26/2025
Our favorite restaurant in Montauk over many years of visits. Delicious food, strong inventive cocktails, lovely service, beautiful landscaping and killer views overlooking the ocean. For our...
Gregg A.
7/3/2025
What a great dinner experience we had. Excellent friendly service. Very good diverse menu. Prices are as expected for this area... "if you have to ask" The sunset dinner on the deck is...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.