Lucie P.
7/12/2025
The cleanest deli I've seen in a long time! The sandwiches were delicious and everyone was super helpful in the store.
Stuff-A-Bagel
$
Open
(37)
Photos
24 E Main St
East Islip, NY 11730
Stuff-A-Bagel is a beloved establishment in East Islip, NY, specializing in freshly baked bagels and a wide variety of delicious fillings. With a commitment to quality and flavor, they offer customers a unique and satisfying dining experience that caters to all tastes.
In addition to their signature bagels, Stuff-A-Bagel features an array of spreads, salads, and breakfast items, making it a go-to destination for both a quick meal and a leisurely brunch. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and dedicated service further enhance the appeal of this local gem.
Generated from the website
Reviews
2.537 reviews
Nicole T.
3/9/2025
Excellent bagels, super friendly staff and clean store. New owners who took over years ago really got their system running well. We are EI natives and only venture here for weekend bagels over the...
Dave A.
12/8/2022
HOLIDAY GO-TO FOR BAGELS on LONG ISLAND! Hanging out in Long Island, NY for Thanksgiving brings a definite change of scenery and atmosphere compared the hustle & bustle of The NYC. The drawback...
Sal P.
6/17/2024
I hadn't been to this store in a few months but it's open early so I gave it a chance. Placed an order by phone at 5:30am to pickup on the way to the beach. The staff person was polite and well...
Kate K.
8/23/2024
Paid over $8 cash for a mini bagel with just tuna. Next time, I learned I should drive up the block to Blue Line for maybe half the price and even better food.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.