haruka o.
11/26/2022
It's my suitemate and I's tradition to get bagels on the weekends. We like to rate bagel stores based on Taste, Location, Price, Atmosphere, Speed. Taste: 5 Location: 5 Price: 3 Atmosphere:...
Strathmore Bagels
$
Closed
(51)
Photos
[479 - 799] Route 25A
East Setauket, NY 11733
Strathmore Bagels, located in East Setauket, NY, is a family-owned delicatessen that upholds a rich tradition of bagel baking dating back to 1905. The establishment prides itself on using fresh and natural ingredients without preservatives, while all bagels are baked in a hearth stone oven and salads are made daily from scratch.
With a commitment to quality and authenticity, Strathmore Bagels offers a variety of catering options for parties and functions, ensuring that every customer feels like part of the Strathmore family. Their skilled team is dedicated to providing excellent take-out service and a limited dine-in experience while maintaining health and safety protocols.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.051 reviews
Tara M.
10/22/2023
Although I love to support local small businesses I have to say honestly that the food here is consistently mediocre. The bagels are dense and my orders end up being wrong every once in a while...
Rachel E.
10/11/2024
Terrible customer service!! I went into bagel store today.. I asked for an extremely small amount of butter on my mini bagels.. they gave me a ton of butter.. I went back to explain it was too...
Heather B.
1/2/2024
This is at the top of my favorite local bagel places. Strathmore always makes the BEST bagels and egg sandwiches. The everything and egg everything never disappoint. The bagels have the right...
Kristin M.
9/24/2023
Asked for a bagel with bacon and cream cheese and got a dry bagel with bacon and literally the thinnest, smallest amount of cream cheese I have ever seen in my life. It also wasn't even on the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.