Orena W.
4/12/2021
Under new management! They are now Bagels Your Way Cafe and they have a new manager, new staff, new menu, new interior designs, and everything. Bagels are still good. I noticed the coffee is now...
Strathmore Bagels
$
Closed
(45)
Photos
999 Montauk Hwy Unit 8
Shirley, NY 11967
Strathmore Bagels in Shirley, NY is a popular local restaurant known for its delicious bagels and breakfast options. With indoor dining and heated outdoor seating available, customers can enjoy a cozy atmosphere while savoring their favorite bagel creations.
Patrons rave about the quality of the food, with many mentioning their go-to orders like bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll. The restaurant's welcoming environment and tasty menu items make it a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.045 reviewsCarol K.
7/29/2025
All the employee's are very nice. The past couple times I've been my egg sandwich was cold.
Justin F.
7/31/2024
This is how bagels and egg sandwiches are supposed to be done! There are some decent bagel places in NC but they just can't compare to the meaty bagels on LI. I also have to get an egg sandwich...
T C.
8/5/2025
Used to be one of the best bagels on LI. Now it is exactly what it looks like - frozen old bagels next to a pet store
Erick M.
10/27/2024
First I called ahead of time 20 minutes giving them plenty of time still had to wait 25 minutes because they messed up the cheese and bagel. Twice then I received a bagel sprinkled with a little...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.