Lisamarie
11/4/2025
Very nice, super friendly and polite staff. My husband and I ordered almost the entire appetizer menu and devoured everything except the French onion soup. Although tasty, I prefer a beef broth...
Starters American Eatery
Closed
(7)
Photos
400 Broadway
Monticello, NY 12701
Starters American Eatery is a dining establishment located in Monticello, NY, known for its welcoming atmosphere and focus on American cuisine. The eatery emphasizes quality ingredients and offers a diverse menu to cater to various tastes.
In addition to its food offerings, Starters American Eatery engages with its community through social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram. The restaurant also provides convenient options for reservations, ensuring a seamless dining experience for patrons.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.57 reviews
Chrystal N.
8/14/2025
Bar tender / server was fantastic! Low key with a cool wavy bar! Decided to stop here as we were passing thru to give it a try! My chicken sandwich was great and my daughter go the ricotta spinach...
Christine T.
4/27/2025
Broadway in Monticello has improved in my opinion thanks to Starters American eatery! From the moment you step through the front door you feel welcomed and comfortable. The cool curvy bar was...
Wendy B.
4/5/2025
Great food! Great service! I had their Greek Shrimp special tonight. Sautéed Shrimp with tomatoes, onions and a hint of dill over rice and Roasted Tomato soup, Perfection!!!!! Must come and try!
Robbie G.
1/28/2025
It's pretty new spot Great bar food , burgers, fried pickles tater tots been a couple of times now and the food is always spot on
See a problem?
