Kytkat66 G.
6/21/2025
I ordered a shrimp wrap it was delicious! My coffee was fresh. The service was excellent the atmosphere in the cafe was comfortable and relaxed. The place was super busy! That's how you know the...
Stars Cafe
$
Open
(68)
Photos
17 Grand Ave
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
We are a small island cafe, serving hot breakfast, coffee, pastries and lunch to both our dear locals and our valued visitors 364 days a year. We have an extensive menu of breakfast items, burritos, soups, salads and sandwiches, delicious gourmet coffee and lovely combinations of coffee flavors. We also have an organic smoothie and juice bar, squeezing us fresh vegetable juices with your choice of superfood spices added, like turmeric, spirulina, protein powder, flax or chia seeds, etc. Come get a taste, you are sure to find something to your liking. We are here every single day, opening as early as 6am and closing between 4 pm and 6pm, depending on the season. Be sure to call us for hours, larger orders, custom cakes or catering before you pop in. We do it all. Our motto is: "STARS CAFE -Where coffee and friends make a perfect blend..."
Also at this address
Reviews
3.568 reviews
Sabrina P.
5/18/2025
Good space for seating and in a prime location right after the ferry in Shelter Island. Lots of options on the menu for sandwiches or breakfast items.
Anjali B.
6/4/2024
Stopped by here on our way out of shelter island. Heard rave reviews about it and clearly we weren't the only ones. It was Memorial Day weekend and a Saturday, absolutely packed in this tiny shop....
Luca P.
12/16/2024
we literally witnessed The owner Scream at a three-year-old for barely touching a cookie. I was eating my lunch. I almost choked. She's known to be extremely nasty The food is mediocre Best. i...
Matt T.
2/25/2025
Wow. The coffee is outstanding and the pastries were the same. I got a muffin and it was really good. Also grabbed some bacon egg and cheese's while in town. Highly recommend this place while you...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.