Spencer's

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(18)

Call
Website

Photos

630 Old Country Rd Ste 2001
Garden City, NY 11530
+1 (516) 747-9162
https://stores.spencersonline.com
Visit Spencer's in Garden City, NY to shop novelty gag gifts, home decor, apparel, sex toys, collectibles, brand merchandise, body jewelry, tumblers, horror finds, gaming merch, incense, posters, and more. Spencer's proudly embodies the mantra, "Life's a party - and we're makin' it fun" by offering an outrageously entertaining in-store shopping experience at over 700 stores in the United States and Canada. At Spencer's, shop the infamous tee wall, laugh at outrageous decor finds, and be sure to explore every inch of the store. From band tees to lava lamps, Spencer's is your go-to for unique gifts for yourself and others. Spencer's also offers the convenient option to buy merchandise online and pick it up in select stores.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.018 reviews
Photo of Napoleon M.
Napoleon M.
11/11/2025

Walking in Spencer's was really humorous! I'm new to this store. Came here to find a wig and mustache but they didn't have it. Customer service is great here; they offer assistance and greet...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Kevin S.
Kevin S.
6/20/2024

So many places sell tee shirts and novelty items. This store stands above the rest. Hot Topic which is a few doors down from here sells some of the same items. What they don't have is the Awesome...

Read more on Yelp
Sarah R.
6/25/2025

I don't know how the employees are trained or if they get commission for selling. But several people I know have been made very uncomfortable by the workers when shopping for sex toys. The...

Read more on Yelp
Nia O.
6/29/2024

Their customer service is . A special type of special. Went to the back of spencers to get something and was eyed the whole time. No clue why. My boyfriend and I were talking to each other about...

Read more on Yelp
Ashley L.
2/22/2024

this store has horrible customer service and return policy is stupid. I purchased a belly piercing today opened wanted to return it the same day denied give me my money back and I had to exchange...

Read more on Yelp
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

Spencer's
Custom and orthopedic shoes, Gift shop, Gift baskets

Spencer's

2
"The customer service in here is always on point! There is this 1 guy who always makes jokes & makes my shopping experience a fun blast. I believe he's a manager there. Well I'm pretty sure of it...."
photo of Angela R.
Spencer's
Custom and orthopedic shoes, Gift shop, Gift baskets

Spencer's

8
•
$$
"Spencer's Gifts is a store that brought back my memories of going to the mall every weekend when my daughter was growing up. I always bought gag gifts for my parents and friends. There's great T..."
photo of Marianne W.
Spencer's
Commercial and industrial building operation, Custom and orthopedic shoes, Shoes

Spencer's

1
•
$$$
"Stores in the Newport Centre Mall come and go. Hopefully this one is a keeper. I have always enjoyed wearing Skechers, they have always been the most comfortable shoes and sneakers that I have..."
photo of Mark S.
United States›New York›Garden City›Spencer's

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.