Siena's Pizza

$$
Open
yelp logo

(40)

Call
Website

Photos

121 Broadway
Monticello, NY 12701
+1 (845) 791-7663
http://www.sienaspizzafamilyrestaurant.com

Siena's Pizza and Family Restaurant in Monticello, NY, invites diners to experience a family tradition steeped in history, where signature dishes are crafted from unique recipes inspired by the Old Country. With a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, their mouthwatering sauces and all-natural pasta aim to replicate the savory flavors reminiscent of Italy.

Renowned for their hand-tossed pizzas featuring light, crispy crusts, Siena's has earned a local reputation as the go-to spot for pizza lovers in the county. The restaurant offers a spacious dining area perfect for large families and groups, while cozy booths cater to more intimate gatherings, ensuring a warm and welcoming atmosphere for all.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.040 reviews
Photo of Michaela V.
Michaela V.
8/11/2024

The most important thing is getting the order right. Failure We ordered delivery and our pizza and supposed to have pepperoni and meatballs... came with only cheese. Recipes shows we were CHARGED...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Lorie R.
Lorie R.
8/20/2025

Was our pizza and pasta place to go when we were in Monticello. Even brought family there who were visiting the casino. Always pleased with our meals and service. Especially liked it when they...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Barbara P.
Barbara P.
11/1/2024

Pizza is MUCH better than the pizza place in Rock Hill. Calzone is "ok". Could add more ham. Hot sub Sienna is good BUT DRY AS A BONE. Really needs some sort of sauce. Wouldn't get that again. But...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Scott G.
Scott G.
1/29/2025

The pizza here is the best in the area. Crispy n crunchy and always cooked the way you want. I like it a lil well done. Tasty sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. When getting to go pizza...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Stefan H.
Stefan H.
9/26/2023

Ordered delivery for 10 people on two occasions, both for lunch. Chicken wings and garlic knots were a huge fail, as was the Caesar Salad! Chicken Parmesan and baked ziti were okay. Pizza was...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Broadway Pizza
Eating places, Pizzeria, chain

Broadway Pizza

5
•
$
"Small pizzeria for take out mostly. Excellent pizza and exceptional eggplant rollatini or parm that is not the thin greasy and heavy breadcrumbs that 95 % of pizza places serve. Fresh eggplant..."
photo of Michael G.
Albella Restaurant
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Pizza restaurants

Albella Restaurant

130
•
$$
"Fantastic Restaurant. Fresh, high quality ingredients prepared excellently every visit. The staff here are friendly and accommodating every time. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who..."
Eating places

Loca Pannini Pizza I

$
Lo Capannina Pizza Deli Inc is a local eatery in South Fallsburg, NY that specializes in serving a variety of pizza and deli items. With a focus on providing quality food options, this establishment caters to the community's cravings for classic Italian dishes and quick bites. Generated from their business information
United States›New York›Monticello›Siena's Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.