Laura O.
6/5/2025
I've had three cookies from Schmackary's to date and will list them in order from favorite to least favorite, as I would my children if I had them: Sweet corn: I can't believe this is my...
Schmackary's
$
Open
(2,336)
Photos
362 W 45th St
New York, NY 10036
Call it “Generation Y’s Answer to the Old American Bake Shop,” Schmackary’s has pushed the classic cookie outside of its comfort zone with an adventurous twist on the traditional cookie. Their award-winning cookies are sold at shows and venues across New York City, delivered by the dozens to people and businesses around the country, and featured in some of the biggest television shows, media outlets and high-profile award lists, solidifying its status as the country’s most in-demand cookie company.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.02,336 reviews
Haley H.
8/17/2025
The cookie was underwhelming As someone who makes homemade cookies all the time, I was disappointed with this cookie. Maybe I have high expectations? I went after lunch and It tasted like it had...
Jeff M.
4/4/2025
Schmackary's 362 W. 45th St. New York, NY 10036 Chocolate Chip Cookie Known as Broadway's famous cookie it was definitely fulfilling. This has the perfecto ratio of chips and was a really...
Barbara S.
9/8/2025
Was around this area and decided to stop in to try a few cookies. It's small inside but luckily it wasn't crowded. Picked up a chocolate chip, oatmeal and lavender cookie. Loved all three, soft...
Jas C.
8/31/2025
never heard of this place. passes but it and felt intrigued. have been on a cookie review all week. we definitely hate crumbl, love insomnia and chip city. BUT i think this right here win all of...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.