I gave it another shot after a few years. This time, the crust was crispier and the sauce had a bit more sweetness. Probably twice the amount of cheese necessary. This place could be a cute...
Santino's Pizza Shack
(31)
Photos
Santino's Pizza Shack is a beloved pizzeria in Elma, NY, known for its authentic Italian flavors and exceptional food service. Established in 1971 by Santino Terio, an Italian immigrant, the restaurant has become a local favorite, offering a wide range of delicious pizzas and other mouthwatering dishes.
With a rich culinary experience and a passion for quality, Santino's Pizza Shack has earned a stellar reputation for its delectable food. From their signature pepperoni pizza to their flavorful BBQ chicken tenders, every item on their menu is crafted with care and served with a smile, making it a must-visit spot for both locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
We live pretty close to this bar/restaurant but rarely stop by. It looks like they did a few renovations and got rid of a lot of their food signage. It looks nicer for sure. We didn't get food,...
Great place!! Great service!! First time trying Santino's and we will be back!!! The pizza was very good with crispy pepperoni!! The chicken wings were also very good!!! They were very crispy...
I like coming here in the summer for the clam shack. 2-3 of us split the high tide. Wednesday was the best day to go. Steven was the work and very friendly and there was NO sand in the clams...
I love coming to Santino's during the summer for clams or clam-a-rama as we call it! Fresh steamed and raw are so so yummy! We went with a group of us and split a pizza which was also delicious.
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.






