Carmine M.
10/7/2025
Sam's. It is what it is A wonderful blast from the past and an unpretentious visit to what the Hamptons used to be. Is it the best pizza in the world? No Is it the hippest of the Hamptons?...
Sam's Restaurant
$$
Closed
(173)
Photos
36 Newtown Ln
East Hampton, NY 11937
Sam's Bar and Restaurant, a long-standing establishment in East Hampton, NY, has been a beloved part of the community for over 60 years. With only one change in ownership throughout its history, patrons can still enjoy the same delicious pizza and salads that have remained a constant since its inception.
Conveniently located on Newtown Lane, the bustling hub of the village's shopping district, Sam's Restaurant continues to be a go-to spot for locals and visitors seeking a taste of tradition in a cozy, familiar setting.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5173 reviews
Nic N.
9/2/2025
The decor and built ins and bar and walls look like they're mostly original from the 1940s which was very cool. Service was easy breezy, greeted pretty promptly, given a wait time and sat down...
Rob J.
8/9/2025
Sam's is a great old school Italian bar and restaurant right in the heart of East Hampton Village... great pizza, pasta and meatballs, and they make a mean martini! Can't wait for a return visit...
Gabriela D.
10/17/2025
Good straight forward food. Pizza was very thing and the small salad was loaded. It took a very long time for someone to take our order and again a long wait for the check. I thought it was a fair...
Jamie N.
8/31/2025
this place is very homey and comforting - it has a very old style to it but was very fitting. we got their small veggie pie and while it kind of looks like a frozen pizza, i really enjoyed it! i...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.