Sal & Carmine's Pizza

I got a couple of slices here because I heard great things about the restaurant and an old family friend used to love it here. I was feeling nostalgic. I ordered one cheese slice and one mushroom...

First time here. Regular slice is huge. Lots of cheese creating a lot of oil dripping off the slice. Undercarriage could use more charring. Dough not nearly enough crisp. Margarita slice....

This place is now trash. I used to come here in the 90s and 2000s and it was IMHO the best slice in NYC. I came back after ~15 years of not coming to relive my youth and I could not get through...

Service was amazing! Came in late witj cash in hand, just as they were cleaning up, and please let me assure you-they were all cleaning EVERYTHING! Even the napkin holders. Makes me really trust...

Although good value, agreed with some of the other Yelp reviewers that the dough a bit thick for their pizza slices. Sauce & meat (pepperoni) both met expectations.