Sara B.
8/23/2017
Don't go to Ruschmeyer's if: -You dislike crowds -You dislike waiting on line for everything (bathrooms, drinks, etc) -You dislike obnoxiously high priced drinks and covers (yes, it's 40 bucks to...
Ruschmeyer's
$$$
(146)
Photos
161 Second House Rd
Montauk, NY 11954
Check-in: 4 PM, Check-out: 11 AM
Evocative of a period nautical summer camp, Ruschmeyer's was originally built in 1952 on three lush acres of lakeside woodlands in Montauk, Long Island. The recently renovated cabin-inspired guestrooms circle a central lawn known as The Magic Garden, with picnic tables, hammocks, and grills designed for both organized and spontaneous leisure. Ruschmeyer's offers a range of activities from bicycling to fishing, ping-pong, paddle boarding and yoga, with lawn games and bubbles for the kids, along with a rotating series of musical performances, theater and artists-in-residence. The culinary team behind The Smile in Manhattan, serves seafood dishes with fresh local ingredients in the main restaurant and outdoors in the garden, while the Electric Eel delivers endless nights of dancing and classic maritime cocktails.
Also at this address
Reviews
2.0146 reviews
Portia B.
9/15/2023
Great choice. Absolutely great. 1.) Consider the area you are staying, Montauk is pricey to begin with and I have seen reviews criticizing the price of drinks (we did not eat or drink here) and...
Jess F.
7/3/2017
Could not be more disgusted with this place. Found out on arrival that groups larger than 8 are forced into a pre-fix menu that doesn't place any consideration on dietary restrictions and costs...
Emily E.
6/27/2021
Went there the night of 6/18, sat in back right corner of the place. Music way too loud. our waitress spilled 4 glasses of RED wine down the back of my head and back. I was soaked, to the point...
Madelaine C.
6/24/2018
The worst service I've ever received. Melody Thomas the matra d and manager was rude, disrespectful, and as a manager seemed incompetent. I've been here the past few years and this experience,...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.