Michael S.
8/19/2025
Rachel's is a must try if you live, or are visiting Ocean Beach. Rachel's is a great choice for delicious food and friendly family service. Enjoy your view of beautiful flowers and interesting...
Rachel's Fire Island
$
Closed
(179)
Photos
325 Bay Walk
Ocean Beach, NY 11770
Rachel's Fire Island is a charming restaurant and bakery nestled in the heart of Ocean Beach, New York. Serving up delectable dishes for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, this cozy establishment caters to locals and visitors alike.
With a menu that boasts a variety of options, from freshly baked pastries to savory entrees, Rachel's Fire Island offers a delightful culinary experience for all tastes. The inviting ambiance and friendly staff make it a popular choice for dining on the island.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5179 reviews
Tony Y.
8/17/2025
Rachel's has been a Fire Island staple for 25 years and it shows. We usually try to do at least one night for dinner here whenever we're out in the Island. What started out as a bakery has now...
Jared S.
10/16/2025
Went to Rachel's last weekend for the first time, just a few days before they closed for the season. The space felt so warm and inviting. We were catching a ferry in 10 minutes so grabbed a quick...
Jessica C.
10/14/2025
First time exploring fire island over the weekend (Sunday). Wish I came here during the summer time because it was a bit chilly. A lot of places were closed, Rachel's was one of the few that...
Jennifer H.
8/27/2025
Great spot, next time I definitely want to try their food as opposed to just baked goods. Pignioli cookie I got was great but definitely not worth $5 for the size of it.
See a problem?
