Glenn S.
5/11/2025
Pastrami Sandwich- I had to have one. I decided to try this deli that nearby & new for me. I ordered hot pastrami on rye. It was expensive, but it was just what I was looking for..I had even...
Pumpernickels Delicatessen & Market
$
Closed
(41)
Photos
734 Route 25A
East Setauket, NY 11733
Pumpernickels Deli and Market is a charming establishment in East Setauket, NY that offers a variety of deli sandwiches, salads, and specialty food items. Customers can enjoy a casual dining experience in a cozy atmosphere or grab items to go.
With a focus on quality ingredients and friendly service, Pumpernickels Deli and Market provides a convenient option for those looking for delicious and satisfying meals in the area. Whether stopping by for a quick bite or stocking up on pantry staples, this local spot caters to a range of tastes and preferences.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
4.041 reviews
Bill S.
5/2/2023
I have to give a shout out to Pumpernickels Deli in East Setauket. You've passed this deli doing 50mph headed into Port Jefferson. There's a well known deli very close to my home, guess what? I...
Charles S.
7/6/2023
Overwhelming menu at first but if you focus on the Ruebens you can't go wrong! A little bit of everything if you're looking for sweet or savory snacks. Really patient staff. Sat outside on the...
Gracie B.
12/31/2022
Great deli with a ton of selections! I recommend their egg sandwiches. The staff is super friendly and the deli is always clean and well organized.
Mary Beth M.
4/4/2024
Great food friendly faces. Parking isn't great but the quality makes up for it. The owner is lovely and the cost is reasonable.
See a problem?
