Shelbee P.
7/5/2025
My favorite pizza place anywhere in New York. No frills, just a sweet older Italian couple making delicious pizza. My family has been going for years, and the first time we went feels just the...
Pugsley Pizza
$
Closed
(212)
Photos
590 E 191st St
Bronx, NY 10458
Pugsley Pizza, located in the Bronx, NY, is celebrated for its authentic Italian pizza experience, featuring generous slices, homemade sauce, and a perfectly crafted crust. The welcoming atmosphere, combined with the delightful food, has made it a popular spot among locals and visitors alike.
Owned by a friendly couple, Pugsley Pizza has garnered rave reviews for its quality offerings and cozy environment, attracting patrons looking for a satisfying meal in a vibrant setting. Its reputation was further solidified at a local pizza festival, where it stood out among numerous competitors, earning a dedicated following.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5212 reviews
Beth C.
9/15/2025
Great Bronx pizza and nice ambiance. We stuck with the basics - excellent pie! The owners are very nice and down to earth.
Maricar T.
10/10/2024
Back in New York City right after my Italian trip, I visit "Little Italy" in the Bronx and found this fun Italian-American spot selling creative pizza that will surely disgust the Italian nonnas...
Sundeep S.
4/23/2025
Excellent pizza $20 a pie. You will love it. Should be on your bucket list of to-go-to NYC pizza joints.
Ray M.
1/6/2025
So my pal and I were in the mood for some pizza and I figured we'd go to one of my favorite spots Pugsleys Pizza up in the Bronx. The owner, Sal and his wonderful wife were at the helms this time....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.