John S.
8/18/2025
This place is incredible. Not only are the cookies delicious and top quality, they also have milks to go with it. Regular, chocolate, strawberry, blueberry and banana and possibly others. The best...
Problem Baker
Closed
(12)
Photos
870 Castleton Ave
Staten Island, NY 10310
Problem Baker, based in Staten Island, NY, specializes in creating large, handcrafted, premium gourmet cookies that can be shipped nationwide. With over 20+ flavors available, customers have the opportunity to mix and match their favorite batch, ensuring a unique and personalized experience.
At Problem Baker, the emphasis is on offering high-quality cookies made with premium ingredients. Each cookie weighs over 4.25 oz, guaranteeing a satisfying treat with every bite. The brand prides itself on providing fast shipping, ensuring that customers receive their gourmet cookies promptly.
By focusing on perfecting classic cookie recipes, Problem Baker aims to deliver delicious treats without compromising on quality. Customers can expect an enjoyable experience and one-of-a-kind flavors in every bite. Whether it's a special occasion or just a craving, Problem Baker promises satisfaction and mouthwatering cookies that stand out from the rest.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
5.012 reviews
David G.
7/25/2025
Pulled up and noticed there was parking in the back which was great. Very convenient. The inside of the place look very bougie and the vibe was chill. The service was quick, one of the girls...
Miranda M.
4/6/2025
A quick and easy pick up from their stall at Philippines Fest's Ubeland! My friend and I enjoyed a classic Ube cookie from here which came individually packaged, as the Ube Dubai Chocolate...
Monique J.
9/6/2025
New fave spot. I'll update once I taste the cookies. Super friendly, clean space. Bonus places to sit inside and outside (no pic)
Mariam S.
8/27/2025
Had been wanting to try them for a while and glad i did ! Owner (male) was extremely professional friendly and helpful. Did a great job explaining his company +purpose and loved that it aligned...
See a problem?
