James S.
10/8/2025
This place hasn't changed in 40 years and that's a good thing. With so many restaurants that come and go, Prima Pizza had been a great mainstay for us and so many others. I know pizza is in...
Prima Pizza
$
Closed
(176)
Photos
252 Main St
Cornwall, NY 12518
Now in its third generation, pizza lovers know it's that the best pizza comes from New York. Maybe it's the water, maybe it's the air, maybe it's the experience - no one knows for sure, but what we all know is the taste of a real New York Pie can not be beat. Using a process invented by proprietor A.J. Scalise, Prima Pizza can ship a 100% natural, preservative-free New York pizza anywhere in the USA overnight. This technique is so innovative there is a patent pending.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0176 reviews
Sara O.
7/22/2025
My favorite Pizza in New York! Served piping hot, cheese melted to perfection! They have the best ranch (huge deal to me) and crisp soft drinks as a perfect pairing to any pepperoni pie! The staff...
Nick M.
3/14/2025
Cute little pizza place located in the heart of Cornwall business district. Pizza so good they ship it. Gotta say I eat at a lot of pizza joints and this place is just cozy, Old fashioned the...
Lawyer278 R.
8/9/2025
Their food and pizza is not good. In my opinion. Their sauce has no taste and they're entrées leave much to be desired for.
Heather H.
5/2/2024
Great little place in Cornwall with good pizza and open on Monday! I love the inside decor and how cute it is. There is a great outdoor patio and a few seating options on the sidewalk to...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.