Preferred Mutual Ins

Closed
yelp logo

(3)

1 Preferred Way
New Berlin, NY 13411
Founded in 1896, Preferred Mutual Insurance Company is one of the leading insurance carriers. Its personal and commercial lines of products are marketed through over 400 independent agencies in New York, New Jersey, New Hampshire and Massachusetts. The company offers various insurance plans and policies for homeowners, boat owners, business owners, artisan contractors and religious institutions. It provides protection coverage for commercial vehicles, personal computers, guns, jewelry, cameras, fine arts, antiques, valuable rugs, rare books and coins. Preferred Mutual Insurance Company organizes various community welfare programs and offers scholarships to local students. It employs more than 250 people at its corporate office and information technology center in Chenango County, N.Y. The company is headquartered in New Berlin, N.Y.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
1.03 reviews
Rick H.
5/30/2025

Terrible customer service! Three times they got the name wrong on insurance ID cards, causing DMV registration issues. Then they corrected the name but changed the VIN number for no good reason,...

Photo of Johnson M.
Johnson M.
3/29/2021

It's crazy to me how Preferred Mutual chooses not to understand the times we are in. I found out that many other insurance companies have covered deductibles for health care workers due to working...

Richard P.
7/9/2019

In my opinion, they are liars and thiefs. They have no intention to pay what your vehicle is worth and will fight you every step of the way. I'm going on my 4th month after vehicle has been deemed...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkNew BerlinPreferred Mutual Ins

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.