Mariam I.
9/21/2025
MUST VISIT!!! 10/10 Bagel Shop. The staff is so kind and helpful. Food & beverage selection is amazing. Everything is fresh and delicious. God bless the owners for all their hard work in creating...
Poppy Seed Bagel & Catering
Open
(28)
Photos
2220 Forest Ave
Staten Island, NY 10303
Poppy Seed Bagel & Catering, located in Staten Island, NY, specializes in handcrafted New York bagels, offering an extensive menu that includes popular options like lox and cream cheese. The establishment prides itself on providing competitive prices without compromising on quality, making it a go-to destination for bagel enthusiasts and those seeking catering for gatherings.
In addition to their bagel selection, Poppy Seed Bagel & Catering also features a variety of muffins and quick lunch options, all available for online delivery. Whether for a casual breakfast or a special event, their catering services ensure a delightful spread that satisfies every craving.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
5.028 reviews
Elizabeth P.
10/28/2025
I stopped by Poppy Seed because I've been wanting to try true Staten Island style bagels, and this spot did not disappoint! I ordered the Mariners bagel, and it was absolutely delicious generous...
Frank P.
9/13/2025
These bagels are awesome. Like they just came out. Great sandwiches and really friendly people working here. Just an excellent experience all around. Thanks
Mario P.
9/4/2025
Best dame bagle in NYC Great service they even gave me free coffee me and my family will be back with the whole crew
Nicholas G.
9/23/2025
Poppy seed bagel shop is indiscreetly located in a strip mall that if you werent looking for you would pass it. It looks like a trendy bagel shop serving all the heavy hitter sandwiches you can...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.