Stephon M.
6/20/2025
Best wings I ever had. I live 40 minutes away. Wish there was more flavors and accepts card but I can't complain at all
Pony's
$
Closed
(68)
Photos
23 Main St
Middleport, NY 14105
Pony's is a popular establishment located on Main Street in Middleport, NY, known for its inviting atmosphere and extensive menu featuring a variety of pub food and drinks. The restaurant is particularly celebrated for its famous sauces, which add a unique flavor to its dishes.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.568 reviews
Ashley E.
4/12/2025
Holy cow!!! We decided to order our from here on a whim because I was getting my hair done. I had the breaded chicken fingers. They were some of the best chicken fingers I have ever had. I ended...
Diana W.
6/17/2024
I took my husband and son here on Father's Day. I've heard a lot of talk about their chicken fingers, so we wanted to try them. We ordered their family bundle. It was more than enough food for...
Dave V.
12/16/2024
My wife and I ordered a Cheeseburger and wings. Great tasting food. Business was very clean. Staff is very friendly. Easy access for anyone with mobility issues. We'll definitely return to Pony's!
Shelbie S.
2/2/2024
Pony's is obviously KNOWN for their fingers/wings/sauce. It's unfortunate that they changed their fingers and fries. Definitely not nearly as good as they used to be. The sauce also seems...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.