Mayuka K.
4/6/2025
Today, I went this bakery for the second time to try different parties. This time, we tried their eclair, the strawberry with custard cream puff pastry, and our favorite cannoli. Their cannoli is...
Polito Bakery
$
Closed
(61)
Photos
3365 Hillside Ave
New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Polito Bakery, established in 1960, has been a beloved institution in New Hyde Park, NY, renowned for its freshly baked goods. Specializing in custom-made cakes for various occasions, the bakery also offers a diverse selection of baked items, pastries, cookies, and Italian ices.
With a wide array of delectable treats such as danish, cannolis, and fruit tarts, Polito Bakery caters to both sweet cravings and special celebrations. In addition to its mouthwatering offerings, the bakery provides catering services to enhance any event with its delicious creations.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.061 reviews
Elizabeth P.
4/25/2025
Walked in today Friday morning and ordered a few items. The woman behind the counter was very nice. The bakery is very tidy. They have a nice variety of goodies. Will definately be back!
Kimberly K.
5/1/2025
Got cakes for my kids for their birthdays and they were delicious ! The staff is so attentive and helpful!
Andrew W.
1/4/2025
I've been to Polito many times before and have always had a great experience. They have a huge selection of pastries and cookies, but the rainbow cookies and St. Joseph's cakes are definitely my...
Nancy Q.
12/24/2023
Very disappointed. I picked up our holiday pastries and opened the box to a smashed up mess. Do you want them in the same box the girl behind the counter asked?! Honey if they don't fit nicely...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.