Joel H.
5/8/2025
So... I have been patronizing Pizza Supreme for about 50 years now... Actually longer as I started coming here as a teen when they were in Roosevelt Field. (Wow, do I feel old.) This place is...
Pizza Supreme
$
Closed
(97)
Photos
678 Stewart Ave
Garden City, NY 11530
Pizza Supreme, a family owned and operated pizzeria, has been serving customers for over 27 years since its opening in Massapequa Park. Known for its famous thin crusted Sicilian pie, the pizzeria offers a wide array of pizza toppings and a full menu of Italian favorites.
Customers at Pizza Supreme in Garden City, NY, are drawn back by the delicious flavors and quality ingredients found in each dish. With a commitment to providing top-notch service and mouth-watering pizzas, Pizza Supreme continues to be a local favorite for those craving authentic Italian cuisine.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.597 reviews
Glenn S.
4/27/2025
I drive 30 miles to get their square pizza. Crust is light, cheese is stringy....outstanding!
Chris Y.
2/9/2025
Best pizza in Nassau County! Service is great. Classic square pie, thin slice, sweet sauce.
Mike H.
7/6/2024
Square pizza is the best around. Been coming here for almost 20 years, when my parents used to bring me. I'm sure the rest of the pizza matches the quality of the square slices, but I just can't...
Bob A.
2/15/2025
Ordered from here for a party at a local gymnastics facility for a birthday party. Pizza was good. Very reasonable. However the delivery guy did not speak a word of English and we were...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.