Penoro A.
9/4/2025
Pizza tastes great walk-in no steps Plenty of free parking Variety of pizza and food indoor and outdoor seating We had square pizza and half each of a slice
Pizza Star
Closed
(13)
Photos
New York Ave # 211
Middletown, NY 10940
Pizza Star is a celebrated Italian restaurant located in the heart of Middletown, New York, captivating food enthusiasts with its authentic Italian pizza and diverse menu since 2018. The establishment offers a cozy ambiance for dining, alongside convenient options for takeout and home delivery, showcasing a range of pizzas, sandwiches, soups, pastas, and more.
Committed to quality, Pizza Star uses the finest ingredients and skilled chefs to craft flavorful dishes that satisfy various palates. Additionally, they provide catering services, ensuring that special events are as memorable and delicious as the food they serve.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.513 reviews
Lucia D.
9/4/2025
Pizza is hot and very good. Friendly service and bathroom available to customers. Very busy location. It is next door to Black Friday deals.
Brianna I.
4/22/2025
As new residents to the area, my partner and I were on the hunt for a good pizzeria. For some time, it was tough to find one that met our standards. We tried pizza star and have since not ordered...
Shareen C.
7/8/2025
This place was one of my favorite places for quick eats. My last visit left a lot of hair in my mouth....literally....not cool. I didn't order extra floss with my sandwich. I wont be revisiting
Carlos S.
12/27/2024
The perfect stop on our road trip from Pittsburgh to Boston. The food was delicious! We tried the buffalo garlic knots and enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. Service and ambiance was just what we needed...
See a problem?
