Rachael B.
11/6/2025
This place was truly a gem! Everything we ordered was delicious. Secret salad - fresh, perfectly dressed, really yummy Stracciatella dip - indulgent but light & delicious. The bread that came...
Pizza Secret
$
Closed
(322)
Photos
72 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11217
Pizza Secret is a casual couzy wood burning pizzeria that makes the authentic Neapolitan cucine with a great selection of Italian beer and wine list. Authentic Gourmet Pizzeria Napoletana as the owner Rosario Granieri is 3ª Generation of Pizzaiolo born and raise in Napoli Italy. This year 2023 Pizza Secret was selected 50 top pizza in place of 17th in United state of America ♥️ Thank you so much to all of you A presto! Grazie Mille. Pizza Secret Team.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0322 reviews
Erin F.
7/4/2025
Not your regular pizza shop in and out in a strip mall. This place is refined dining with inside and outdoor seating. Staff was attentive and prices reasonable, including a happy hour cocktail....
Mike R.
8/14/2025
ABSOLUTELY AWFUL. First time and LAST TIME ordering. Marguerita was undercooked and did not travel well during delivery. All of the cheese slid off to one side. And / the worst part ........
C J.
10/29/2025
The food was amazing. I just came back from Italy but the experience here makes me feel like I never left. The service was top notch. The ambiance is romantic and cozy. I can't recommend it enough.
Letty C.
6/16/2024
The sun was out. It was an extremely busy day in Park Slope. Fifth Avenue on a Saturday is extremely busy, Pizza Secret was a welcoming surprise. We were seated quickly in their sidewalk seating....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.