Austin J.
7/15/2025
Pizza spot in the middle of nowhere that tasted like a pizza spot NOT in the middle of nowhere...if that makes sense. I enjoyed it. People say I'd get the plague. I didn't not get the plague....
Pizza Plus
Permanently closed
(34)
Photos
37249 State Highway 23
Roxbury, NY 12474
Pizza Plus, located in Grand Gorge, NY, is known for its exceptional fresh pizza and some of the best garlic knots in the area. The establishment prides itself on providing great friendly service and offers a diverse menu that includes wings and other tasty options.
With a commitment to quality food and customer satisfaction, Pizza Plus is a favorite spot for both locals and visitors alike. Guests can enjoy their meals either by dining in or opting for pick-up.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.534 reviews
Tom B.
11/4/2025
While my wife and I were inside eating our pizza, which was fine, someone ran in and said my car had been smashed in the parking lot. I confronted the driver who appeared intoxicated. Turns out it...
Chris R.
4/1/2025
We stopped into Pizza Plus after a hike at Mike Kill state park. I had a slice of pepperoni pizza and a buffalo chicken salad. The pizza was fantastic. It was more like a NYC slice than anything...
Eric R.
1/8/2024
This place is awesome! I was visiting the Roxbury area (about 8 miles down the road) but the small restaurants in the town I was visiting were too small to accommodate the influx of tourists to...
Alexa P.
1/27/2025
It was ok. Slim pickings in the area. But half of the pizza was thin and a little burnt while the other half was fluffy. We ordered only 2 ingredients on our pizza but only received one topping...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.