Kim T.
10/27/2025
Just what a slice should taste like! Good crust, good sauce and good cheese. Lots of regulars!
Pizza Pete's
$
Closed
(186)
Photos
528 Columbus Ave
New York, NY 10024
Pizza Pete's is a beloved local pizzeria located on Columbus Avenue in New York City, renowned for its delicious array of pizza options, including classics like Cheese Pizza and Fresh Mozzarella Pizza. With a focus on customer satisfaction and a community-centered approach, Pizza Pete's has become a popular destination for residents seeking quality food and a memorable meal experience.
In addition to their tempting pizzas, the menu features mouthwatering appetizers, salads, calzones, and hearty heros, ensuring there is something for everyone. Whether dining in or opting for convenient curbside pickup, guests can indulge in great flavors while enjoying affordable prices at this iconic neighborhood establishment.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5186 reviews
Woody W.
11/3/2025
First time here and the pizza is decent, but the service was terrible. Can't figure out why people in the service industry are so grumpy? Don't think anyone asked or made you take your job. Sad...
Mosa H.
9/15/2024
Decent cheap slice. Not super fresh but a good, greasy drunk snack. Could be cleaner, limited seating, soccer on the TV. Cashier/employee was friendly and pizza was fast to come out.
Van V.
2/4/2024
Just wanted two slices quick. Pizza Pete's can do two slices quick as lots of pies are in the case. Man at counter was very nice. It is a tiny place in a busy block with lots of eateries. I had...
Lindsey K.
10/16/2023
Pizza Pete's is good! I got a slice of pizza, garlic knots (5) with marinara, and a side of ranch all for $8! I was impressed with how quick my food was ready too. I know it's just another pizza...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.