Craig M.
9/29/2025
Great service. Best Italian food around. Great pizza, granda pie's and the veal is the best I've had in years!
Pizza Italia NYC
$
Closed
(21)
Photos
3593 Bayview St
Seaford, NY 11783
Pizza Italia NYC is a local pizzeria situated in Seaford, NY, offering a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas.
With a focus on quality ingredients and fresh flavors, Pizza Italia NYC provides a casual dining experience for customers seeking classic Italian cuisine.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
5.021 reviews
Noah K.
11/11/2024
Just moved from Lido to Wantagh driving around looking for my new pizza joint. Stella's didn't cut it, nor did Wantagh pizza. Glad I found Pizza Italia. Apparently it's the home of the round...
Lizzie H.
2/5/2024
The pizza was so good we came back a day later but through Uber eats - hey it was late & freezing on a Sunday. Don't judge us But now I can confirm NOT ONLY does their food travel well but their...
Alex K.
9/4/2024
Pizza Italia hits the spot and then some! When there's a billion pizzerias on Long Island, sometimes it's nice to go old school, pick up the phone, and order from your local spot! The square...
Tara L.
1/20/2025
My mom always caters and we always order food from here and we are always amazed by how good everything is. This place makes the best pizza and they cater the best hero's. They make it exactly how...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.