Piece A Cake

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(417)

Photos

177 New Dorp Ln
Staten Island, NY 10306

Piece-A-Cake Bakery in Staten Island was founded by James and Maria Carrozza in 2012. This establishment, their third bakery venture, stands out for its café section offering a variety of breakfast items, soups, salads, and sandwiches. Among their offerings are desserts a la mode, cake by the slice, cookies, pastries, and even ice cream, ensuring a diverse selection for every sweet tooth.

In 2016, the bakery expanded to include a second location, The Cookie Jar, conveniently situated adjacent to Piece-A-Cake. The Cookie Jar boasts an array of cookies, whimsical cookie jars, shakes, and the popular Toasted Marshmallow Milkshake, adding a fun twist to the overall bakery experience. Located at 177 New Dorp Lane, Staten Island, this bakery is a focal point on the bustling street.

Piece-A-Cake Bakery's mission is simple yet impactful - to delight customers with scrumptious offerings crafted from top-quality ingredients and time-tested recipes. The establishment aims to ensure that every patron departs satisfied and content, living up to its name as an effortless and enjoyable experience.

Generated from the website content

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0417 reviews
Photo of Dona F.
Dona F.
8/1/2025

As a bakery this place is most likely the best in Staten. (I know everyone has their favorite!). Came here for breakfast and had a ricotta omelette with a side of bacon. Whole wheat sour dough on...

Gabrielle G.
10/23/2025

I'm extremely disappointed with my experience at this bakery. I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes on Sunday, paid $135, and everything went smoothly -- so I placed the exact same order again on...

Photo of Lisa A.
Lisa A.
10/10/2025

This business literally just sent a lunch order to a school without one meal. We even spoke to the guy on the phone about the meal after placing it online. NO phone call, NO heads up, NO call to...

Photo of Kim M.
Kim M.
5/26/2025

Staff recently have been really nice. Wish they put back breakfast service. We bought the Dubai chocolate cake. By far DELICIOUS a must try!! Not sweet or super rich.. really a perfect dessert

Photo of Lynn D.
Lynn D.
2/18/2025

Coffee's pretty good but the service is even better. Love that it's connected to the cookie jar so you can enjoy the ambiance of both unique places while sharing desserts & coffees .. great date spot!

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.